Facts: Mr Hughes was a young man who was severely disabled, mentally and physically. He was cared for at home by his mother, with help from outside agencies. Liverpool acknowledged, however, that his mother’s accommodation was wholly unsuitable for him. An assessment concluded that he needed suitable accommodation and, also, respite care. However, none was provided.

Judgment: Mitting J held that Liverpool was in breach of section 21 and 29 of the National Assistance Act 1948, by failing to meet Mr Hughes’ assessed needs. He ordered respite care to be provided each weekend, and a re-assessment of the mother’s needs. He rejected, however, a claim for damages under the ECHR.